The fastest way to judge a sushi bar is to order three pieces of tuna side by side and taste the difference. If you’re looking for the best sushi in Lehigh Valley, skip the star ratings for a minute and run that test yourself: lean Akami, medium-fatty Chu-Toro and extra-fatty O-Toro, in that order. At Okatshe, Chef Jose Garces’s modern Japanese izakaya and sushi restaurant at 947 Hamilton St in downtown Allentown, all three sit on the sushi bar menu as nigiri, sashimi or hand rolls.
Most search results for sushi in the Lehigh Valley are lists of restaurant names. They tell you where people went, not how to tell good sushi from forgettable sushi. This guide is for the diner in Bethlehem, Easton, Emmaus or the suburbs who wants to know what to order, what to look for, and whether a sushi night downtown is worth the drive.
Key Takeaways
- Judge a sushi bar on nigiri and sashimi before rolls, because sauces and tempura in a roll hide the fish.
- The tuna ladder (Akami, then Chu-Toro, then O-Toro) is the clearest single test of a sushi bar, and Okatshe Allentown serves all three.
- Range matters: yellowtail, Hokkaido scallop, sweet shrimp, eel, white tuna, tamago and seared A5 Wagyu tell you how deep the sushi bar goes.
- For two or three people, the Okatshe Platter plus a few cold plates is the easiest way to taste across the menu.
Check Out Our Menu!
1. How Do You Judge the Best Sushi in Lehigh Valley?
You judge it piece by piece, starting with the simplest orders, because a plain slice of fish over rice has nowhere to hide. Rankings and listicles can tell you a place is popular. They can’t tell you whether the rice holds together, whether the fish tastes clean, or whether the chef cuts each piece to suit the fish.
So set your own test, starting with a few pieces of nigiri and sashimi:
| What to check | What good looks like | What goes wrong |
|---|---|---|
| The rice | Holds its shape on the way to your mouth, then loosens | Packed hard, or falling apart before you pick it up |
| The fish | Clean taste, no fishy smell, soft or firm as the cut should be | Dull, watery or overly cold |
| The cut | Size suits the fish; rich cuts thinner, lean cuts thicker | Every piece cut the same way regardless of fish |
| Range | Several kinds of tuna plus other fish and shellfish | Salmon and tuna only |
| Rolls | Sauces support the fish | Spicy mayo on everything |
Our clear position: start with nigiri and sashimi, then move to rolls. Rolls are great, and we’ll get to them. But a roll loaded with crunch and sauce tells you about the sauce. A single piece of Hamachi tells you about the fish.
One more test that most people skip. Taste a piece with no soy sauce first.
2. Nigiri vs Sashimi vs Hand Roll: Which Should You Order?
Order nigiri if you want to judge the rice and fish together, sashimi if you want the fish alone, and a hand roll if you want something crisp and eaten in a few bites. Okatshe’s sushi bar sells each piece three ways, so you can pick the format fish by fish.
Nigiri is a slice of fish pressed over a small mound of seasoned rice. Sashimi is the fish on its own, sliced and served without rice. A hand roll (temaki) is a cone of seaweed filled with rice and fish, and it’s meant to be eaten right away while the seaweed still snaps.
| Format | What it is | Good for | Tip |
|---|---|---|---|
| Nigiri | Fish over a small mound of rice | Judging the whole bite, rice and fish together | Eat it in one bite if you can |
| Sashimi | Sliced fish, no rice | Tasting the fish on its own | Good for comparing cuts of tuna side by side |
| Hand roll | A cone of seaweed with rice and fish | A casual, crunchy bite | Eat it as soon as it lands, before the seaweed softens |
For a first visit, we’d mix them. Take the tuna as sashimi so the differences between cuts stand out, then order Hamachi and Hotate as nigiri to see how the rice is handled.
Hand rolls are the bite to finish on.

3. The Tuna Ladder: Akami, Chu-Toro and O-Toro Side by Side
The tuna ladder is three cuts of the same fish, ordered from leanest to richest, and it’s the quickest way to see how a sushi bar handles its fish. At Okatshe Allentown, the sushi bar lists Akami (lean tuna), Chu-Toro (medium fatty tuna belly) and O-Toro (extra fatty tuna belly).
Eat them in that order. If you start with O-Toro, the leaner pieces taste flat after it.
| Step | Cut | What it is | What to notice |
|---|---|---|---|
| 1 | Akami | Lean tuna | Deep red, clean and meaty, the baseline |
| 2 | Chu-Toro | Medium fatty tuna belly | Softer, with more richness coming through |
| 3 | O-Toro | Extra fatty tuna belly | Pale and marbled, close to melting |
Akami is the honest one. It’s lean, so you taste the fish itself with nothing to soften it. Chu-Toro sits in the middle, and for a lot of diners it’s the sweet spot: rich enough to feel like a treat, with enough body to still taste like tuna.
O-Toro is the indulgence. It comes from the fattiest part of the belly, and one piece is often enough.
If you only order one thing on your first visit, make it this ladder. Two people can split the three cuts and compare notes.
Chef Jose’s Signature Tuna Ceviche makes a smart follow-up. It uses akami with leche de tigre and coconut, which shows the same lean tuna dressed a completely different way.
4. What Does Range Say About a Sushi Bar?
Range tells you how much care a sushi bar puts into the menu beyond the usual salmon and tuna. A short list can still be good, but a longer one gives you more ways to test the kitchen and more reasons to come back.
Okatshe’s sushi bar goes well past tuna:
- Hamachi (yellowtail): buttery and mild, a good second fish after tuna.
- Hotate (Hokkaido scallop): sweet and soft; as nigiri, it shows off how the rice is seasoned.
- Ebi (sweet shrimp): delicate, with a natural sweetness.
- Unagi (broiled eel): cooked, smoky-sweet and an easy entry for raw-fish skeptics.
- Binaga (white tuna): lighter in color and flavor than red tuna.
- Tamago: a Japanese egg omelet, cooked rather than raw.
- Seared A5 Wagyu: Japanese wagyu beef, seared, for the steak lover at the table.
Two of these deserve a special mention for mixed groups. Unagi and Tamago are both cooked, and so is the seared A5 Wagyu. That means a friend who doesn’t eat raw fish can still order from the sushi bar instead of sitting it out.
5. Rolls With a Point of View: From Tiradito to the Garden Roll
Once you’ve tasted the fish plain, rolls are where a sushi bar shows personality. At Okatshe, a few rolls carry Chef Garces’s Latin American background, and those are the ones we’d point you to first.
The Tiradito Roll is the clearest example. Tiradito is a Peruvian raw-fish dish, and here it becomes a roll of hamachi, avocado and cilantro, topped with sriracha and more cilantro. Chef Garces built his name on Spanish and Latin American cooking, and this is where that shows up on a Japanese menu.
The classics are all on the list for anyone who wants a familiar order:
| Roll | What’s in it | Order it if you like |
|---|---|---|
| Rainbow | California roll topped with tuna, hamachi and salmon | A bit of everything |
| Dragon | Unagi and cucumber, topped with avocado and sweet soy | Sweet, cooked flavors |
| Spider | Fried softshell crab, cucumber, asparagus, sweet soy | Crunch |
| Midnight Eel | BBQ unagi, tamago, toasted panko, sweet soy | Rich and savory |
| Firecracker | Shrimp tempura, cucumber, avocado, carrot, firecracker sauce | Heat |
| Emerald | Scallion, cucumber, shishito, topped with torched binnaga | Something lighter |
| Garden | Chef’s selection of seasonal vegetables | Vegetarian sushi |
The Garden Roll matters more than it looks. A sushi night only works if everyone at the table can order something, and vegetarian guests get a proper roll here rather than a cucumber afterthought.
6. How to Build a Full Sushi Night at an Izakaya
The easiest way to eat at an izakaya is to mix sushi with small plates, so plan your order in rounds rather than as one big sushi plate. Okatshe is an izakaya first, modeled on the late-night spots Chef Garces got to know in Tokyo while filming Iron Chef.
Start cold. Spicy Tuna Crispy Rice, Hamachi Crudo with jalapeño and house ponzu, and Salmon Tartare with guacamole and wontons all set up the sushi nicely.
Then the sushi bar.
Then something hot for the table, especially if not everyone eats raw fish. Edamame, the handmade dumplings, Spicy Confit Wings and Miso Black Cod all suit a sushi night.
For two or three people, the Okatshe Platter is the shortcut. It brings California, Spider and Garden rolls, six pieces of nigiri chosen by the chef and four hand-rolled temaki. We’d order it alongside two or three cold and hot plates rather than as the whole meal, since it’s designed as a shared centerpiece.
For a bigger table, look at the tasting menus. The Tokyo Tasting brings Chef Garces’s favorite izakaya plates family-style, and the Kyoto Tasting is his signature progression with premium additions.
| Your table | What to order | Why |
|---|---|---|
| Two, first visit | The tuna ladder, Hamachi nigiri, one roll | Tests the sushi bar without over-ordering |
| Two or three, hungry | Okatshe Platter plus two cold plates | Covers rolls, nigiri and temaki in one order |
| Four to six | The Tokyo Tasting plus a round from the sushi bar | Shared plates keep everyone eating together |
| A special night for two | The Kyoto Tasting | The chef’s progression, no decisions needed |
| Mixed group, some non-raw | Seared A5 Wagyu, Unagi, hot plates, Garden Roll | Everyone orders from the same menu |
To drink, ask the team to suggest something from the curated sake list to match your order. Japanese whiskies, beers and craft cocktails are on the menu too.
7. Sushi in Allentown, PA for the Whole Valley: Getting Downtown
Okatshe sits at 947 Hamilton St, in the middle of downtown Allentown’s dining and entertainment district, so a sushi night is easy to pair with a show or a game. If you’re coming from Bethlehem, Easton, Emmaus or the suburbs, plan the evening around something nearby and the drive feels like part of the night out.
The PPL Center is steps away. It hosts concerts and is home ice for the Lehigh Valley Phantoms, so sushi before puck drop works well: order a round of nigiri and a roll or two, tell your server you have tickets, and walk over.
Archer Music Hall is close by too. Before a standing show, go lighter, with sashimi and a hand roll rather than a full tasting menu.
Staying at the Moxy Hotel? Okatshe is right in the neighborhood.
Parking is available nearby downtown. And after the show, Okatshe offers late-night dining and drinks, so you can come back to Hamilton Street for a whisky and one more piece of O-Toro.
Planning a longer visit to the region? Discover Lehigh Valley lists things to do across the Valley, from Bethlehem to Easton.
Book Your Sushi Night at Okatshe Allentown
Pick a night from Wednesday through Sunday, bring someone to split the tuna ladder with, and judge the sushi yourself. If you’re searching for the best sushi in Lehigh Valley, reserve a table at Okatshe Allentown and start with Akami, Chu-Toro and O-Toro side by side. For groups too big for a regular booking, the large group events team can plan a custom menu or a sushi-rolling class.
Frequently Asked Questions
Can I order sushi from Okatshe for takeout?
Yes. Okatshe takes takeout orders through Toast online ordering, so you can pick up sushi and small plates from Hamilton Street. For a party or office event, the Okatshe catering team handles larger orders.
Is Okatshe a good choice if I have a food allergy?
Tell the team about any allergy when you reserve, and they’ll accommodate it. Mention it again to your server when you sit down, since sushi bars handle shellfish and other common allergens.
Can we learn to make sushi at Okatshe?
Groups can. Okatshe offers sushi-rolling classes and curated culinary experiences for groups, arranged through the large-group events team. It works well for team outings and celebrations where everyone wants to get hands-on.
What’s the difference between a maki roll and a hand roll?
A maki roll is rolled into a log and sliced into rounds, while a hand roll is a single cone you hold and eat in a few bites. For a deeper look at rolled sushi, read our guide on what a maki roll is.
Is there a service charge for larger sushi groups?
Yes. A 20% automatic service charge applies to tables of six or more at Okatshe. If your group is bigger than a regular booking, the large-group events team can help plan the night.

